• Skip to main content
  • Skip to secondary menu
  • Skip to primary sidebar
Exterminating Angel Press

Exterminating Angel Press

Creative Solutions for Practical Idealists.

  • Home.
  • Our Books.
  • About Us.
    • What EAP’s About.
    • Why Exterminating Angel?
    • Becoming Part of the EAP Community.
    • EAP’s Poetry Editor Speaks!
    • Contributors.
    • EAP Press.
  • EAP: The Magazine.
    • EAP: The Magazine Archive
  • Tod Blog.
  • Jam Today.
  • Contact Us.
  • Cart.

Mousetraps.

December 31, 2018 by Exangel

by Bruce Thompson.


My friend and mentor R. B. Angell—Brad to those of us who knew him—always kept a mousetrap beside his computer. It was primed and ready to snap at any moment.

“Do you have a problem with mice?” I asked him on one of my visits to his house.

“No,” he replied, a little puzzled that I would ask such a question

“Then, why the mousetrap?” He laughed as he realized what I was referring to.

“The mousetrap is to remind me that there really are causal relations. ‘If I touch the trigger, then it will snap’.”

Brad and I had met at a philosophy conference about a year before. We were logicians, working in the same (very narrow) field of logic. Specifically, we were what could be called “logical realists,” although the technical term is “connexivists.” We had never met prior to running into each other at that conference. However, we knew of each other’s work because he had politely rejected a paper of mine for publication—and I had agreed that he was right to do so. At the time, I was a recent Ph.D. graduate working at my first real job; he was a distinguished scholar, and my paper was full of the errors one might expect from a rank beginner. After he rejected my paper, I avidly researched his work, and come to the conclusion that he was perhaps the most brilliant and important logician of the 20th Century. I have not since wavered in that opinion. Meeting him was, for me, like meeting Aristotle.

We talked for what seemed to us like barely ten minutes. His wife, Imogene, stood beside him, smiling at the pleasure her husband felt in talking to someone who knew and understood his work. I looked at my watch and realized that we had been talking for over an hour. I was mortified that we had been so inconsiderate as to talk so long, leaving his poor wife surely bored to tears. She reassured me that, while she had not understood a word we said, she was delighted that her husband had met a kindred soul.
Brad taught at Wayne State University in Detroit. He invited me to teach an introductory logic course (as a visiting instructor) during the summer semester. At the time, I was living in Erie, Pennsylvania. My classes at Wayne State met on Tuesday and Thursday afternoons. My weekly schedule was to drive from Erie to Detroit on Tuesday morning, and arrive in time for my afternoon class. I would then go to Brad’s house, where he had a guest bedroom. I would spend Tuesday and Wednesday nights with Brad and Imogene. On Thursday, I would meet my class again—and then drive home to Erie.

Wednesday was the height of my week: Brad and I would spend the whole day going over our current work in connexive logic, debating which principles were foundational axioms, which were derivable theorems, and how one could go about proving “logical completeness” for connexive systems.

It was on one such Wednesday that I noticed his mousetrap.

Connexive logic is an attempt to formalize a logic in which real causal “connexions” are recognized. We believe that a statement such as “If the moon is made of green cheese, then it is raining,” is false, since there is little connection between the chemical composition of the moon and the current weather. Most people who are not trained in formal logic agree with us; so, it may surprise you to learn that the standard logic, upon which all computer science is based, holds that this statement is true! Since the moon is not made of green cheese, the “if…then…” proposition is true by default. Under Boolean logic, any “if…then…” statement is true merely because its antecedent is false (or its consequent true), and for no other reason. Underlying causes (if any) are irrelevant. Of course, this has profound implications for artificial intelligence research. How can we expect a computer to think like a human being, when human beings understand and reason about real causal connections, while computers do not, and cannot?

I asked Brad, “Do you ever touch the trigger on the mousetrap?”

“Never!” he replied. “The mousetrap is there to remind me that the statement ‘If I touch the trigger, then it will snap’, is true whether I touch the trigger or not.”

Humans make decisions believing that choices have real outcomes. We avoid certain actions because we know what the consequences of those actions would be—even if those actions are never taken. Causality is not a truth-table. Yet, every connexivist has moments in which the quest for a non-Boolean logic seems futile. Perhaps the Booleans were right after all. When Brad had such moments, he would see his mousetrap and wonder how badly it would hurt to stick his finger just … Brad was using the mousetrap to stay grounded, to resist the temptation to give up, to remind himself not to be seduced by the easy convenience of Boolean truth tables.

Brad Angell died in 2010, not long after completing his work, The A-Logic, which he had been working on during the summer I spent with him. I doubt that his work will have much influence on modern logicians. It is too far outside the mainstream of modern logic—which is to say, it is utterly brilliant, and therefore unlikely to be appreciated. My own work has been far more conservative. I have tried to hew closely to the expectations of modern logicians in the hope that my work would someday be understood and appreciated—which is to say, my work is not especially brilliant. But, remembering Brad’s mousetrap, I have not given up.

The mentor-protégé relationship is something special in academic circles. It is hard to describe. Is it like a father-son relationship? Not really. Brad and I knew each other for barely a whole year; but, it was one of the most influential years of my life. I can say this: if I had not known Brad and Imogene, then my life would have been quite a bit different and infinitely poorer. There is a real causal connection between their lives and mine.

Filed Under: EAP: The Magazine, Winter 2019: Triggers.

Primary Sidebar

Cart.

Check Out Our Magazine.

In This Issue.

  • Who Was Dorothy?
  • Those Evil Spirits.
  • The Screaming Baboon.
  • Her.
  • A Tale of Persistence.
  • A Conversation with Steve Hugh Westenra.
  • Person Number Twelve.
  • Dream Shapes.
  • Cannon Beach.
  • The Muse.
  • Spring.
  • The Greatness that was Greece.
  • 1966, NYC; nothing like it.
  • Sun Shower.
  • The Withering Weight of Being Perceived.
  • Broken Clock.
  • Confession.
  • Francis Coppola’s Apocalypse.
  • Sometimes you die, I mean that people do.
  • True (from “My Life with Dogs”).
  • Fragmentary musings on birds and bees.
  • 12 Baking Essentials to Always Have in Your Poetry.
  • Broad Street.
  • A Death in Alexandria.
  • My Forked Tongue.
  • Swan Lake.
  • Long Division.
  • Singing against the muses.
  • Aphorisms from “What Remains to Be Said”.

In The News.

That cult classic pirate/sci fi mash up GREENBEARD, by Richard James Bentley, is now a rollicking audiobook, available from Audible.com. Narrated and acted by Colby Elliott of Last Word Audio, you’ll be overwhelmed by the riches and hilarity within.

“Captain Sylvestre de Greybagges is your typical seventeenth-century Cambridge-educated lawyer turned Caribbean pirate, as comfortable debating the virtues of William Shakespeare, Isaac Newton, and compound interest as he is wielding a cutlass, needling archrival Henry Morgan, and parsing rum-soaked gossip for his next target. When a pepper monger’s loose tongue lets out a rumor about a fleet loaded with silver, the Captain sets sail only to find himself in a close encounter of a very different kind.

After escaping with his sanity barely intact and his beard transformed an alarming bright green, Greybagges rallies The Ark de Triomphe crew for a revenge-fueled, thrill-a-minute adventure to the ends of the earth and beyond.

This frolicsome tale of skullduggery, jiggery-pokery, and chicanery upon Ye High Seas is brimming with hilarious puns, masterful historical allusions, and nonstop literary hijinks. Including sly references to Thomas Pynchon, Treasure Island, 1940s cinema, and notable historical figures, this mélange of delights will captivate readers with its rollicking adventure, rich descriptions of food and fashion, and learned asides into scientific, philosophical, and colonial history.”

THE SUPERGIRLS is back, revised and updated!

supergirls-take-1

In The News.

Newport Public Library hosted a three part Zoom series on Visionary Fiction, led by Tod.  

And we love them for it, too.

The first discussion was a lively blast. You can watch it here. The second, Looking Back to Look Forward can be seen here.

The third was the best of all. Visions of the Future, with a cast of characters including poets, audiobook artists, historians, Starhawk, and Mary Shelley. Among others. Link is here.

In the News.

SNOTTY SAVES THE DAY is now an audiobook, narrated by Last Word Audio’s mellifluous Colby Elliott. It launched May 10th, but for a limited time, you can listen for free with an Audible trial membership. So what are you waiting for? Start listening to the wonders of how Arcadia was born from the worst section of the worst neighborhood in the worst empire of all the worlds since the universe began.

In The News.

If you love audio books, don’t miss the new release of REPORT TO MEGALOPOLIS, by Tod Davies, narrated by Colby Elliott of Last Word Audio. The tortured Aspern Grayling tries to rise above the truth of his own story, fighting with reality every step of the way, and Colby’s voice is the perfect match for our modern day Dr. Frankenstein.

In The News.

Mike Madrid dishes on Miss Fury to the BBC . . .

Tod on the Importance of Visionary Fiction

Check out this video of “Beyond Utopia: The Importance of Fantasy,” Tod’s recent talk at the tenth World-Ecology Research Network Conference, June 2019, in San Francisco. She covers everything from Wind in the Willows to the work of Kim Stanley Robinson, with a look at The History of Arcadia along the way. As usual, she’s going on about how visionary fiction has an important place in the formation of a world we want and need to have.

Copyright © 2025 · Exterminating Angel Press · Designed by Ashland Websites